Friday, January 15, 2010

"Crime is a Way To Use the City"...and so is camo

When reading one of the most recent pieces on BLDGBlog, I was struck by how the writer describes how criminals and crime-fighters use the urban space to defeat their opponent. It's like chess, sure, but without rules: climbing through elevator shafts, breaking through walls and ceilings, and basically using any which way to get through a building to the objective without using doors. Sure, the writer uses Die Hard as his example, but its still applicable to Central Asia.

Local Knowledge is, I think, always the criminal's greatest asset. Whether you're talking about Taliban, Hekmatyar, or whoever in Afghanistan or smugglers in Tajikistan or anti-government opposition groups in, well, most anywhere, the criminal usually must leverage their knowledge of their environment for their own protection. And the more sci-fi and creative they can be, the better off they usually are.

As a result, government groups invest in technology to leverage their economic advantage. They get pretty sci-fi and creative themselves, as you can see every time you click on Danger Room. Drones, missiles, special forces all rely on leveraging technology and training, but even still they cannot realistically execute One Shot-One Kill attacks. Even more, armed groups like the Taliban, who used to take to the mountains, have now begun to take to urban areas to use the city as camoflauge and protection. The Quetta Shura is now in Quetta, not just Somewhere in the Mountains. It is a whole lot more difficult to isolate the Quetta Shura in an urban world, geopolitics between the nation-states aside. They can use the entire built environment as layers and layers of camoflauge allowing them to plan and meet without fearing an instant attack. In this case, the city can beat the technology.

But what about smugglers and their warehouses? Here, corruption can trump intelligence gathering. Knowledge of the city and the city's weaknesses allows drug runners to avoid arrest, if not detection. If the city is not camoflauge, it can also be armor.

So as much as some folks have derided the new ISAF plan to "take the cities" there is some logic and forward-thinking to it. If ISAF can prohibit Neo-Taliban folks and their cadres from entering the city, ISAF can then get them into the open, where they are more susceptible to the ISAF's technology advantage. ISAF can prohibit the Neo-Taliban from using the city as camoflauge or armor. This presumes, of course, that Signals Intelligence can combine with the work of the ANP to really put a squeeze in the rurality, and that this squeeze is still a sincere goal, not just "opening up" the already relatively opened up cities for Kabul to extend its influence. But if the "take the cities" approach is meant to be proactive, than its a bright move to put the Neo-Taliban to a disadvantage and one of the first real proactive strategies ISAF has had since 2008 or so (I'm sure that I'm going to be corrected on this, or pointed to some date closer to 2001. Correct/point away!).

ISAF can, and security forces from Afghanistan north to Kazakhstan can, choose between using greater force (Eyal Weizman has a fascinating, if a bit politically-charged, essay on Lethal Theory that is a must-read as far as I'm concerned) or greater policing (which involves lots of words to be spilled on corruption, of course). It's not a true dichotomy, but it brings up questions involving how to fight the War on Terror and the War on Drugs. I've mentioned Nazrif Shahrani before, and I think it's important to ask how to view these Wars through other perspectives. It's as much about creating a legal environment as it is a secure environment, in my opinion. And how the security forces choose to view the population centers, be it as dangerous wildernesses that must be tamed or as bastions of order that need coaxing, can affect how these Wars will be viewed by the populations themselves.

If Crime is a way to use the city, then the goal is to mitigate the crime while promoting the city. It is complex, sure, but proactive solutions can lead to successful resolutions, and those have been rare to come by recently.

2 comments:

  1. Breitling Watch in 18k Gold and animation case with blooming credible casting is able cut out for connoisseurs. Navitimer World has All-overs White chaw with Montbrillant Datora sub-dials Date indicator at the 3 mark Unidirectional Ratcheted Breitling Avenger Cambered azure anxiety proofing on both carelessness.

    I regularly buy Louboutin Shoes , so I have many shoes in my Christian Louboutin Boots box for two seasons, although they are my best good. Christian Louboutin Sandals can be more and more girls and sexy good girl must keep intact all the time flat, charming and attractive. Buy cheap shoes, many Christian Louboutin Pumps ?

    When buying portable HOPE AND FAITH , make sure you carefully examine basic features such as display resolution and battery of life for maximum efficiency. You can expect newer models of HOPE AND FAITH DVD player to arise in the coming years as this technology continues to improve its quality and offer more innovation. These newer HOPE AND FAITH DVD COLLECTION models will also introduce more advanced features that will enable you to enjoy more functionality and entertainment however you like it

    ReplyDelete
  2. Moreover, to know what is in-vogue these days, greatly help you to buy a perfect Coach Purses , Purse or Handbag. This will also improve your confidence level as you will be wearing the just right Coach Hamptons that is in-fashion these days. Although, Coach Luggage to look stylish and sure with ideal Coach Madison , handbag or a purse, you should put in some time and effort to find a store that has the entire range you are searching for.


    A favorite choice from the collection of Hardy clothing for fall and winter 2010 include the stylish and trendy Filina Satchel. The fashionable tattoo art adorned handbag has a western theme accentuated by colorful and unique fringe details. The hardy shirt signature logo is also featured on the Filina Satchel as is the famous hardy shirt art depicting tiger embroidery, hardware, and a zipper pull and buttons all with an ED Hardy Shoes theme.


    Every scarpe Hogan combines art, top quality material, comfort, and the Hogan scarpe uomo design and cut that goes with every great creation. Hogan uomo is no wonder then that shoes from hogan donna remain the only choice among the worlds top athletes, specially the worlds finest basketball players.

    ReplyDelete