Monday, January 25, 2010

Keep all my kicks in they case thats glass, aye

What do Cool Kids have to do with the Rule of Law? Nothing, really. But still:



Now that classes started up again, I'm going to try and be a bit more law-focused than I've been in the past. But I got struck pretty hard yesterday when a professor casually mentioned that in order for the rule of law to work, the state must have a monopoly on law like they ought to for a monopoly on violence. It's why I'd be more worried about the Taliban's Sharia courts then I would be about violent insurgency, if I was going to talk about Afghanistan. History is littered with failed armed uprisings, but courts that get listened to generally follow adhesion to a person or an idea.

It is awkward to state from an American perspective, but there is certainly a moral dimension to the war in Afghanistan. I'm sure one of the more Socy/Anth folks (or a real, live, actual, Afghan) would have more to say on the subject, but how Kabul brands its vision of Afghanistan, and how the Taliban brand their vision, are really the most divergent parts of their ideologies. And the Taliban get the Law-and-Order label.

It wasn't that long ago where news came stateside that the Kabul government is instituting the same laws that we thought ISAF was supposed to be stopping. And poor Karzai has to try to keep his government Afghan enough for respectability while being American enough to show Powerpoints demonstrating progress to ISAF. All the while, folks like Ashraf Ghani have vague, unactable ideas about how to turn Afghanistan into Pennsylvania. Say what you want about the Taliban, they have a clear moral compass. I have yet to hear any stories on widespread corruption on the lower levels of the insurgency. If people feel they can trust the white lines of Taliban rule (even if they stem from black tar) then they'll pick the Sharia-based justice system over the indeterminately-Western version.

Without a monopoly on justice, the fighting, the development, is all just assorted dead leads. Smuggling, violence, corruption, all stem from the lack of jurisdiction and the image of moral dubiousness coming from Kabul. You could, and many have, argued about what the Big Leading Factor is for the insurgency in Afghanistan. If you, like me, suppose that the lawlessness is the factor, then there are different sets of solutions than what are typically looked at. When Kabul begins a decent, cohesive, vision of what it's Afghanistan will look like, then Kabul can take the initiative. A constitution that wasn't made in Germany isn't a bad place to start.

1 comment:

  1. Coach Outlet is now the leading American marketer of accessories made with suede and leather Coach Poppy fabric. Each product is of the highest Coach Madison quality and made using only the best leather. Their craftsmanship and quality is something that has been tested through time. Coach Luggage that were made during the 1940’s are still in excellent condition showing customers just how durable they are.

    The evolution of ED Hardy Shoes brand is a magic. What do Madonna, Britney Spears, Snoop Dogg and Sylvester Stallone all have in common? No, hardy shirt not the newest romantic scandal in Hollywood - In recent years one line of clothing has been by worn by all these celebrities and many more. It's not Gucci, Louis Vuitton or Burberry, its hardy shirts , the hottest new brand by French designer Christian Audigier.


    Hogan scarpe are the stuff of legends in the sporting world. hogan donna is the unparalleled provider when Hogan scarpe donna comes to sporting apparel like shoes. What sets them apart are not only the name or the extensive marketing operation that the Hogan scarpe uomo undertakes to promote the product but also the quality and art that goes with all shoes products.

    ReplyDelete